| Cast List | Actor |
| Sweeney Todd (Benjamin Barker) | Alexander Krick |
| Mrs. Nellie Lovett | Kelly Kantner |
| Judge Turpin | Peter Snow |
| Anthony Hope | Angel Soto |
| Johanna Barker | Malāna Wilson |
| Tobias Ragg (Toby) | Titus Newswanger |
| Beadle Bamford | Stephen Stankiewicz |
| Beggar Woman (Lucy Barker) | Lindsey Villecco |
| Adolfo Pirelli (Daniel O’Higgins) | Jacob Galarza |
| Jonas Fogg | David Bitler |
| Bird Seller | Elizabeth Fry |
| Ensemble | |
| Alice Ozga-Wojno | |
| Amy Hudak | |
| Cody Hoppes | |
| Colleen Klahr | |
| David Bitler | |
| Delia Misciagna | |
| Elizabeth Fry | |
| Grace Albert | |
| Jeff Yoder | |
| Josue Tinoco | |
| Karen Pepe | |
| Mark Christy | |
| Mary Stankiewicz | |
| Matthew Allen | |
| Megan Martin | |
| Regan Hutchins | |
| Sarah Geiger | |
| Seth Harkins | |
| Shirley Pisano |
Josh Jarmoski